
Nicholas Creamery Promo Code Black Friday 2026
nicholascreamery.com
4 offers to explore · Updated
SAVE ON YOUR NEXT ORDER
Latest Nicholas Creamery Discount Code
Get a Free Celebration Plaque with Cake Purchase at Nicholas Creamery
From $55: Get Creamery Cakes at Nicholas Creamery
Nicholas Creamery Deal: As Low as $4 on MERCH
No offers match this filter.
Recently Expired Nicholas Creamery Discount Code
Past promotions for reference. These offers may no longer be redeemable.
Stocking Stuffer! Nicholas Creamery Egift Card
Gift Card Stocking Stuffers
Sign up for Nicholas Creamery to Get $2 off your next order
Sign up for Nicholas Creamery for $2 off your next order
Save $2 on Your Order
Popular Nicholas Creamery Discount Code
| Code | Discount | Offer | Expires |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deal | Gift Card | Gift Card from $10 at Nicholas Creamery | See merchant |
| Deal | Free Gift | Get a Free Celebration Plaque with Cake Purchase at Nicholas Creamery | See merchant |
| Deal | FROM $55 | From $55: Get Creamery Cakes at Nicholas Creamery | See merchant |
| Deal | FROM $4 | Nicholas Creamery Deal: As Low as $4 on MERCH | See merchant |
About Nicholas Creamery
Nicholas Creamery is a small-batch ice cream shop in downtown Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey. Chef Nicholas Harary and Melissa Harary founded the business, which churns its own ice cream and relies on ingredients sourced close to home, a practice the shop calls farm-to-spoon.
Scoops come in familiar varieties alongside less ordinary creations such as Bourbon Chocolate Chunk, Hudson Café Coffee Crunch, and Vegan Coconut Cherry Vanilla. Servings are made to order, milkshakes are spun by hand, and ice cream cakes can be ordered for celebrations and gatherings.
Partnering with nearby farmers lets the creamery feature New Jersey produce and dairy while staying close to the community around it. Nicholas Creamery runs more than one shop in New Jersey, and customers can also take pints home, pick up digital gift cards, and sign up for The Pint Club loyalty program, which earns points toward coupons and offers.
Merchant information
Confirm current details directly with the merchant.
- Address
- 586 River Road, Fair Haven, NJ, 07704-3221, US
- Official social profile
- https://www.facebook.com/nicholascreamery
- Official social profile
- https://www.instagram.com/nicholascreamery
- Organization
- Nicholas Creamery
How to Use Nicholas Creamery Promo Codes at Checkout
Codes go into the promo code box at the Nicholas Creamery checkout; deals need no code.

Choose a code
Pick a code from the list above. Its details give the discount and any conditions, such as a minimum spend or an end date.
Reveal and copy it
Select Show Code. A window opens with the full code, a Copy code button and a link to nicholascreamery.com.
Apply it at checkout
Add your items at nicholascreamery.com, then paste the code into the promo code box in your cart or at checkout.
Check the total
Make sure the discount shows in the order total before you pay. If it does not, the order may not meet one of the code's conditions.
Ways to Save at Nicholas Creamery
Does Nicholas Creamery have a military discount?
Yes, Nicholas Creamery gives active military members and veterans an ongoing 25% off on one coffee or ice cream. The offer is valid in-store only, and a valid military ID or proof of uniform is required.
Does Nicholas Creamery have an app discount?
Yes, the Pint Club app from Nicholas Creamery includes a loyalty program in which you can buy 10 pints and get 1 free, collect points on purchases, and skip the scoop line by paying directly in the app for to-go items.
Does Nicholas Creamery have a teacher discount?
Yes, Nicholas Creamery offers in-store discounts, frequently 20% to 25% off during Teacher Appreciation Week, with a valid teacher ID. Calling ahead or checking the shop's Instagram is the best way to learn about current promotions.
Does Nicholas Creamery have an employee discount?
Yes, employee discounts are available at Nicholas Creamery's New Jersey locations, with both on-shift and off-shift discounts.
Does Nicholas Creamery sell gift cards?
Yes, Nicholas Creamery sells digital gift cards starting from $5. They suit small treats or saving toward larger orders, and they never expire.
Do new customers get a discount at Nicholas Creamery?
Yes, Nicholas Creamery gives new customers a $5 first order discount when they sign up by SMS. It usually applies to the next order only.
Questions About Nicholas Creamery Promo Codes
Why might my Nicholas Creamery promo code not work?
A code fails when the order misses one of its conditions, such as eligible products or a minimum spend, or when the promotion has ended. Each offer's details list its conditions.
How many Nicholas Creamery offers are there?
There are 4 Nicholas Creamery offers on this page: 4 deals.
Can I combine Nicholas Creamery promo codes?
No offer on this page says whether it can be combined with others. Checkout normally takes one code per order.
Is there a Nicholas Creamery rewards program?
Yes, Nicholas Creamery runs "The Pint Club" rewards program. Points earned on purchases bring coupons and offers, and buying 10 pints gets you 1 free. You can join through a Square Profile or an in-store QR code.
Nicholas Creamery Social Accounts
Nicholas Creamery Categories
Browse more stores in Nicholas Creamery’s categories.